"Sin and Desire in Analytic Theology: A Return to Genesis 3" (Sarah Coakley)
Sarah Coakley
90.42
31 January 2017
20 August 2025
Sarah Coakley, Norris-Hulse Professor of Divinity at the University of Cambridge AAR & SBL Annual Meetings in San Antonio, Texas November 20, 2016 Abstract: The 'problem of evil' has dominated modern analytic philosophy of religion, with 'original sin' merely seen as a further complication for the 'free will defense'. This lecture starts from a different direction: a close exegesis of the Genesis Fall narrative itself, with a focus on 'sin' as misdirected desire. Drawing on a rich set of alternative renditions (from rabbinical, Greek, Syriac and Latin sources), a typology of contrasting classic accounts of sin is essayed. While each generates a theodicy problem of its own, a favoured philosophical solution emerges, intensifying rather than dissolving the classic felix culpa paradox, but freshly illuminating the relation between desire and freedom.
