You Tube Theology

Theology videos from YouTube

YouTube video thumbnail
Extra-Long (>70 mins)
New Testament
AnglicanEvangelical

Is Doubt a SIN? The TRUTH About Suffering, Trauma & Faith in Black America

Theologian

Esau McCaulley


Duration

72.17


Uploaded to YouTube

7 October 2025

Added to Database

12 October 2025


YouTube description

"If God is for us, why is all this happening to us?" That is the question at the heart of Christian faith. For those wrestling with doubt, trauma, and systemic injustice, this panel of leading scholars—Dr. Frederick Haynes III, Dr. Esau McCaulley, Dr. Sarita Lyons, and Rev. R. Janae Pitts-Murdock—delivers a courageous and urgent theological response. They argue that questioning God is not a failure of faith, but an act of worship. Find out when your questions become spiritually dangerous and how the Black church tradition has uniquely battled the "Slave Bible Hermeneutic."

Discussion Highlights & Clips:

(04:02) Can God Handle My Questions? The Biblical foundation for doubt (Abraham, Job, Jesus).
(09:24) The "Gideon Question": Why are we still catching hell? Systemic bigotry & white Christian nationalism.
(13:21) Trauma and the Cross: Why God didn't use His omnipotence to stop my suffering.
(20:08) The Slave Bible Hermeneutic that survives today.
(27:13) The danger of external focus: We need a Jesus who can fix me.
(35:08) Creating SAFE SPACE in the church for questions.
(43:18) I have heavy doubt and feel I'm losing my faith. Is doubt a sin?
(55:09) Spiritual warfare and the limits of apologetics.
(1:07:44) The Final Answer: Questioning God vs. Asking a Question.

What are your toughest questions for God? Let us know in the comments below!

🙏 SHARE this video with someone wrestling with doubt or trauma.
This conversation was hosted by the Jude 3 Project at the Courageous Conversations Conference 2023.

Subscribe for more conversations that help you know what you believe and why you believe it.

Support the mission and vision of Jude 3 Project here: https://www.jude3project.org/donate

Grab our curriculum here: https://www.jude3project.org

Take an online course that will help you know what you believe and why here: https://learn.jude3project.org/library/